The first round of the 2025 NFL Draft is complete, and it delivered plenty of drama, unexpected slides, and bold moves that will shape franchises for years to come. Analyst Pete Prisco has released his grades for all 32 selections, and several teams stood out — for better or worse.
Jaguars Score Big with Travis Hunter Pick – Grade A+
The Jacksonville Jaguars made headlines by trading up for Travis Hunter, the dynamic two-way star from Colorado. Known for his elite skills as both a cornerback and wide receiver, Hunter brings rare versatility and athleticism to the Jaguars' lineup.
Analysts, including Pete Prisco, gave this move an A+, calling it a franchise-altering decision. The Jaguars recognized an elite talent and made the aggressive move to get him — a decision that could pay major dividends in the AFC South.
Giants Raise Eyebrows with Jaxson Dart Pick – Grade C-
One of the most debated selections of the night came from the New York Giants, who took quarterback Jaxson Dart. While Dart showed promise at Ole Miss, many scouts believed he was a Day 2 prospect.
The Giants’ decision to select him in the first round received a C- grade, with critics citing concerns about his mechanics, decision-making, and readiness for the pro level. With several offensive linemen and defensive playmakers still on the board, this pick is being questioned across the league.
Shedeur Sanders Goes Undrafted in Round 1
Surprisingly, Shedeur Sanders, one of the most anticipated quarterbacks of the 2025 class, was not selected in the first round. While teams may have been cautious due to scheme fit or developmental concerns, Sanders is expected to come off the board early in Round 2.
His slide has become one of the most talked-about storylines, and his eventual landing spot could define his career arc and a team’s quarterback future.
Other Top-Rated Picks from Round 1
-
New England Patriots earned a B+ for selecting offensive tackle Will Campbell, solidifying protection for their young quarterback and embodying new head coach Mike Vrabel’s power football philosophy.
-
Buffalo Bills received an A for drafting cornerback Maxwell Hairston, praised for his coverage skills and high ceiling.
-
San Francisco 49ers took wide receiver Ricky Pearsall at No. 31, considered a luxury pick with mixed reviews, ultimately earning a B-.
Biggest Surprises and Reaches
Besides Sanders' fall and Dart’s rise, there were other unexpected developments:
-
Seattle Seahawks shocked fans by passing on a top defensive lineman in favor of a project tight end.
-
Dallas Cowboys went heavy on defense again, reinforcing their identity under new defensive coordinator changes.
Expert Reaction to Round 1 Strategy
Pete Prisco emphasized that this draft could be remembered for how teams valued positional versatility and team fit over traditional draft board rankings. Several franchises chose system-specific players rather than chasing hype.
Teams like the Jaguars, Bills, and Patriots appeared laser-focused on immediate impact and long-term development, while others, like the Giants, might be taking bigger risks.
What’s Next in Rounds 2 and 3?
With Shedeur Sanders, several top-tier edge rushers, and offensive linemen still available, the second day of the 2025 NFL Draft promises more intrigue. Expect a run on quarterbacks and defensive playmakers early in Round 2.
Final Thoughts: 2025 NFL Draft Round 1 Delivered
From Travis Hunter’s bold selection to Shedeur Sanders’ slide, the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft had no shortage of surprises. With teams like the Jaguars capitalizing on elite talent and others like the Giants facing criticism, the outcomes of these picks will be felt throughout the league for seasons to come.